Not legitimate in what context? I think Ken gave pretty clear reasons, with specific examples, that effectively illustrated why most "calls for Israel's dismantling" are in fact protected speech under both the First Amendment and most school's code of conduct. Even if you think those examples he gave constitute violence, it's pretty clea…
Not legitimate in what context? I think Ken gave pretty clear reasons, with specific examples, that effectively illustrated why most "calls for Israel's dismantling" are in fact protected speech under both the First Amendment and most school's code of conduct. Even if you think those examples he gave constitute violence, it's pretty clear that the courts largely do not agree with you. That doesn't strike me as very simple.
I don't give 1 ppm F what "the courts" think. I don't believe in the courts, I definitly do not revere them as some sort of biblical level truth.
It seems people forget that "legitimate" and "legal" are not synoninous, and that there are things private institutions can (and imho should) do that the governmant shouldn't.
It is not legitimate in the contwxt of being a sane human being with any sembkance of morality.
Not everything you can say, you should say. And the fact you do not break the law doean't mean we shouldn't ban you from polite society.
Not legitimate in what context? I think Ken gave pretty clear reasons, with specific examples, that effectively illustrated why most "calls for Israel's dismantling" are in fact protected speech under both the First Amendment and most school's code of conduct. Even if you think those examples he gave constitute violence, it's pretty clear that the courts largely do not agree with you. That doesn't strike me as very simple.
I don't give 1 ppm F what "the courts" think. I don't believe in the courts, I definitly do not revere them as some sort of biblical level truth.
It seems people forget that "legitimate" and "legal" are not synoninous, and that there are things private institutions can (and imho should) do that the governmant shouldn't.
It is not legitimate in the contwxt of being a sane human being with any sembkance of morality.
Not everything you can say, you should say. And the fact you do not break the law doean't mean we shouldn't ban you from polite society.