211 Comments

I don’t know if it matters, but what you do, which I tripped over by accident, has been critically important to me since the advent of the new anti-enlightenment loosed on America by the last president. Your work is comfort. Your work has kept me from making a fool of myself when discussing politics or law. You are an anxiety antidote for me and, I suspect, many others. Even when you upset me by revealing that I’m not going to get the legal outcome I desperately want, I’m grateful to be disabused of layman notions of the law. Just wanted to let you know.

Expand full comment

Seconding this. We're so thankful for you, Ken.

Expand full comment

Two additional notes, Ken.

One is addiction and sobriety. Addiction wraps itself up with both depression and anxiety, and its lowering of inhibitions opens the door wider to acting on suicidal thought.

You do NOT have to go AA/12-step route. There are secular alternatives like Lifering, lifering.org, and SMART Recovery. Please pass this on.

Second may be more controversial yet, but, with men in particular, it's the role of guns in suicides. In an ever-more-absolutist stance, many gun orgs don't even want to talk about addressing this.

Expand full comment

Thank you for putting this out there; both notes are tremendously important.

Expand full comment

I don't think we talk about the gun issue enough, frankly. So many people who attempt suicide -- who perhaps could be pulled back -- don't ever get that chance because they use a firearm. Or, if they survive, they do so with devastating injuries.

If you have a history of depression/anxiety and, especially, suicidal ideation, you should not own a gun, or live in a place where one is easily accessible.

Expand full comment

I'll add this: CNN notes the suicide rate jumped to 14.9 per 1,000 in 2022. And it reminds us all of the 988 speed dial number for the suicide hotline. https://www.cnn.com/2023/08/10/health/suicide-deaths-record-high-2022/

Expand full comment

Dammit, we tried. We talked, we intervened, we hauled him to appointments, we tried to convince him he was important to us. We told him and tried to show him we loved and needed him. He did it anyway. I still feel like a pitiful older sibling who could not catch my younger brother before he killed himself.

I’m glad you are winning, Ken. Keep it up.

Expand full comment

In the end, it's not your fault. Sometimes the best you can isn't good enough, and that's ok.

Expand full comment

My brain agrees, my heart has more trouble accepting that I was not a failure. Thank you for your kind words; Monday was the anniversary so I’ve been a bit ragged.

Expand full comment

I lost my younger brother the same way. Anniversaries are so hard. From one older sibling to another, trust that he did know you loved him. You did everything you could, but their pain was too much to carry. Reassure yourself every day through your own pain that you were enough. Many healing thoughts to you and your family.

Expand full comment

And to you. I’m so sorry you lost a brother this way. It hurts.

Expand full comment

You didn’t miss catching him. You can’t cage a create that doesn’t want to stay. Thanks for being strong enough to hold the loss and tell us. I am sorry he couldn’t stay here with you.

Expand full comment

Depression lies

Expand full comment

You tried, but no one can win against death. Some people just lose the fight more quickly.

Expand full comment

Ken, About 8 years ago I contacted you about my son who was at the time in San Francisco and was quitting his anti-depressant cold turkey. He was able to get off of the anti-depressant and has been doing well since then. He has had some mild cases of depression but I think his current lifestyle has helped. Since that summer, he got his Bachelors degree from The University of Chicago and will be finishing his Doctorate in Evolutionary Biology at Berkeley in May. Thank you for your words of encouragement those many years ago. Keep up the advocacy.

Expand full comment

Ken that was so perceptive and honest. Isolation and self destructive conduct go together. Reaching out is like a periscope allowing you to see beyond the rut you are in. I have lots of severe depression in my family (and me to a lesser degree). My youngest daughter is a successful research scientist in remote sensing, but she would not last a month in her demanding job without her weekly CBT and to a lesser extent her psychiatrist. Her success despite a debilitating condition reminds me of you.

I thought the silence around O’Connor’s death screamed much louder than words. That allows each individual to fill in the context with his or her often malignant imagination. Sometimes context is essential. Take Robin Williams--who battled depression and addiction quite successfully. Many people would attribute his decision to take his own life to such a past. But it turned out he was suffering from an irreversible case of Lewy body dementia, which is about the worst way imaginable to end your life. Totally changes how his act should be interpreted.

I admire your writing greatly--no matter the topic.

Expand full comment

Thanks Ken. The more depression and anxiety is talked about in a thoughtful manner with vulnerability, the less stigma it will have attached to it, people will more likely seek help for it, and people will feel less like they're alone in the fight.

Expand full comment

Thank you. Everyone here on the Irish border is carefully acting like they loved her so much (or not) and now she's just over like a poem when the book is closed. I'm having a hard time with that because I will admit that I wanted to reach out to her as a peer, and I didn't. I mean, who the hell am I to feel like reaching out to a celebrity in pain, right? What could I have done? Nothing, says my Northern Irish husband. Something, says my American Jewish heritage. Maybe.

If someone told me when I was 30 that when I was 56 I'd feel guilt and shame over the death of a rock star, I'd tell them they definitely had it wrong. And sure, my therapist would say not to feel those things unless I was at fault. So, OK, I won't assign myself that blame. But I could have followed up on my impulse to send her a note recognising that she was having a hard time and telling her I appreciated her. That I didn't makes me sad. Good sad. The kind that teaches me not to be so timid next time. And that's a lot of what she was about, to me. A life of not being so timid. Maybe.

Expand full comment

If your therapist tells you to not feel feelings, you need a new therapist <3 i mean that with love and concern cos thats not how feelings work, and moving through life unmoved by tragedy and feeling in others is to be disconnected from humanity. The desire to connect, especially with someone who is suffering, who means something to us, is admirable and deeply ok. You’re equally not responsible for not doing so. I’m sorry this lesson is learned in sadness. Thank you for sharing it, your words touch me deeply. When I was 17, the girl I had a crush on in my literature class died in an accident. I’d not told her how I felt for a bunch of reasons, telling myself it was because girls won’t accept confessions from girls. At her funeral, her siblings and cousins talked about her coming out. It smashed my heart a second time. Until this moment, I hadn’t realised how strongly that pushed me into rushing into telling people how much I feel about them. Your words made me remember my horror and grief and fear of it happening again. I hope you find courage, rather than fear like I did.

Expand full comment

Thanks Ken. I have personal experience with suicide of a close loved one and I’ve become keenly aware the very keywords you mention in news articles and death. Sinead O’Connor’s death landed with me, not only as a longtime fan (we’d not heard anything like her before), but also as human being who knows suffering. I appreciate your willingness to talk about it in an honest and forthright way. All too often it’s couched as a “selfish” act when the person considers it an act of love by removing a burden from loved ones lives. It’s a complicated thing and deserves careful, nuanced discussion.

Expand full comment

My dad committed suicide in 1969 at age 43. I found in him in the garage behind the wheel of his 1967 Mustang with the engine running. Back then the only treatment for major depression was Lithium and ECT. My wife also attempted suicide at age 22 and again at age 48. Was hospitalized several times, at the Mayo Clinic and Cedars Sinai. Received numerous ECT treatments. Luckily, she is doing well now at age 62. On Seroquel, Lithium, and Cymbalta.

For anyone out there suffering with major depression or disabling anxiety, seek treatment. It's readily available. And today's treatments are far more successful in causing remission of the illness (I don't believe it's ever cured.) than in 1969.

Expand full comment

Low dose Ketamine also does wonders especially for depression that is difficult to treat like PTSD. Unlike regular antidepressants, it works in days not weeks. The most effective method is an infusion which can be a bit expensive but there are also companies like Mindbloom which offer programs that allow you to be evaluated at home by medical professionals via zoom and then have the medicine shipped to you.

The data on this has shown a lot of promise. I’m not affiliated with them in any way. I just wanted to make people aware that there are better options now than in the past. I say this not only as a pharmacist, but also as patient who used ketamine in the past and might not be here today without it.

Expand full comment

Thank you for this, Ken. I’m really down in it right now, struggling with suicidal thoughts. A couple nights ago I walked deserted country roads at two in the morning, and thought about what it would mean for me to disappear. I’m doing a little better today but I’m still really, really depressed. Hearing that you’ve struggled too makes me feel a bit better about my own rough patch. I’m really fighting to stay on this earth. Thanks again, Ken.

Expand full comment

Ipso, you don’t know me but it’s worth saying that I’m glad you’re still here. You matter, you are important, and you are loved.

Expand full comment

Thank you for this.

Expand full comment

Ipso, what Ken says is true: depression is a liar. You matter. Your life here is important. Don't believe the lie. Please look for professional help. Despite what depression would have you think about your life, you are definitely worth it.

Expand full comment

Please keep fighting. I've been where you are, a few times. If you have a doctor you trust (like a primary care doctor) ask them about antidepressants to take the edge off a bit. Then, you may be better positioned to decide what to do next. I am 60 and I will be taking them for life, and I'm okay with that. Not everyone needs to, but I do. I hope you stick around. Sending you a hug.

Expand full comment

Please stay, you matter. It matters that you stay. It matters that I stayed. Thank you for fighting to stay and for how you have fought all along. Thank you for your honest and deep sharing here: you matter.

Expand full comment

What a beautifully written and sensitive article. Thank you.

Expand full comment

Thank you so much for talking so openly about this. It's so important for people to read pieces like this, especially from someone with your reach and writing ability. I'm grateful you were able to get the help you needed and are now willing to share about this.

Expand full comment

I had so many more words typed out but all it really came down to was this: thank you, Ken.

Expand full comment

Thank you, Ken. I follow you for your legal insights (and excellent writing). But this is the best.

Expand full comment

Thank you for sharing this. I've been in the dark space too -more than once. When you're there, you can't remember what it's like to not be there so it's nearly impossible to make rational decisions. Robin Williams hit me hard and so as Sinead O'Connor.

Here's another perspective. I'm a high school teacher. I've lost 3 former students to suicide in the past couple of years. I was on the periphery of their lives and yet I was devastated. No matter how little you think you matter in someone's life, you do indeed matter. There is not a single former student in my 25 year career I wouldn't be thrilled to have reach out to me. If it's too hard to tell me your struggling with mental health, ask me my opinions on the latest election or SCOTUS decision. I'll chat with you, even at 2 in the morning. And if the people on the periphery of your life care this much, the people in your inner circles care even more. Please let someone help you out of that dark hole. There are more of us who know how awful it is than you imagine.

Expand full comment

After this particularly shitty day of a particularly shitty week in which everything that is wrong with me physically and mentally seemed to conspire to prevent me from accomplishing even the most menial and mindless tasks, while deadlines for big projects loom, thus further paralyzing me with anxiety.

I just remembered I had an email notification from your account left unread. Reading this today helps if for no other reason than to remind me that I am beating myself up for being beaten up by circumstances I cannot control. I’m not a worthless person even if I didnt prove my worth with accomplishment today. I will try again tomorrow.

Thank you! It is very generous of you to let us in. It definitely helps me keep the frustrations of living in perspective when someone I admire understands the darkness I wish none of us have had to know.

Expand full comment

Your worth is not in your accomplishments. You are a human being and there is an intrinsic value in that. You are more than anything you can accomplish. Your life matters just because you are you.

Expand full comment